23 SEP 2026 · Space Nuts: Water on Mars, Moon Water Limits, and Hunting for Ocean Worlds
Andrew Dunkley and Professor Fred Watson unpack three space science stories tied together by one big theme: water, and where it might be hiding in the solar system. They also answer audience questions on exoplanet detection, dark energy, black holes, and the role of AI in astronomy.
In this episode, Andrew hosts and Fred Watson explains the science across a wide-ranging Q and A format, with contributions from listeners Hussein, Martin, Peter, Dave, James, and others in the live audience. The main topics are Mars gullies, lunar water supply for future settlements, and methods for spotting ocean worlds around distant stars.
Key topics
In this episode: new research suggests Martian gullies may be shaped by dry ice, not liquid water, through a process Fred likens to an air hockey effect.
The Mars discussion explains why older water-based theories struggle, especially in polar regions where temperatures and pressure make liquid water impossible.
The team compares two dry-ice mechanisms for Mars gullies, including a geyser-like burst model and a slower sliding sheet model, with the latter favored.
In this episode: a lunar water study raises doubts about whether there is enough usable water at the Moon’s south pole to support large permanent cities.
Fred explains why the south polar craters are so important for Artemis-style exploration, but also why the terrain is difficult and the water supply may be limited.
The conversation notes that a village-scale lunar base may be feasible, but a city of tens of thousands or hundreds of thousands looks unrealistic on current estimates.
In this episode: the show turns to exoplanets and a new way to look for ocean worlds using glint, the same reflection effect that helped reveal liquid seas on Titan.
Fred describes how coronagraphs and direct imaging could help identify Hycean worlds, though the method only works under strict geometric and observational conditions.
Audience questions cover radial velocity detection, including how astronomers separate multiple planets in a star’s wobble using precise measurements and Fourier analysis.
Another listener asks about dark energy as a propulsion source, and Fred argues the energy density is far too small on any practical scale to power spacecraft.
Peter’s black hole question leads to a discussion of angular momentum, with Fred confirming later that accreted material does add angular momentum to a black hole.
A final discussion touches on AI in astronomy and SETI, including data analysis, paper marking, and the idea that extraterrestrial intelligence itself might be AI.
Timestamps
00:00 - Opening banter and setup for a water-themed episode
01:22 - Mars gullies and the question of whether water is really responsible
04:40 - Why Mars gullies are tricky to explain with Earth-like assumptions
05:23 - Early water-based theories for Martian gullies
06:44 - Why polar gullies rule out liquid water
08:11 - Dry ice on Mars and the shift to carbon dioxide mechanisms
09:07 - Geyser-like dry ice bursts and why the idea was rejected
11:31 - The favored sliding dry-ice sheet model
13:05 - The air hockey analogy for Martian gullies
14:30 - Lunar water and the challenge of building settlements on the Moon
16:03 - Shackleton Crater and the south polar water-ice theory
17:30 - Why the Moon may not have enough water for a large city
19:29 - The Chang’e 7 hopper and future lunar prospecting
22:20 - Recycling, imported water, and using lunar water as rocket fuel
24:07 - Looking for ocean worlds beyond the solar system
25:50 - How Cassini detected Titan’s liquid lakes by sun glint
27:09 - What counts as a Hycean world
28:08 - The University of Arizona study on glint geometry
29:35 - Why direct imaging and coronagraphs matter
30:32 - How the Habitable Worlds Observatory could use the technique Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/space-nuts-astronomy-insights-cosmic-discoveries--2631155/support.